A combined system collects wastewater (toilets, kitchens, bathrooms) and stormwater in the same pipe. A separate system carries them in two distinct pipes: wastewater to the treatment plant, stormwater to a natural outfall or a retention structure. The separate system is now generally preferred for new extensions, but it is the public network operator that sets the rule for your area.
Quick comparison
| Criterion | Combined | Separate |
|---|---|---|
| Number of pipes | One | Two |
| Initial cost | Lower | Higher |
| Behaviour in heavy rain | Risk of saturation and overflows | Undiluted wastewater, no overloading of the treatment plant |
| Treatment plant | Receives large volumes of rainwater | Receives wastewater only |
| Risk of misconnection | Low | Real: a wrong connection cancels out the benefit of the system |
The case of Marrakech
Academic studies of the city describe a public sewer network of more than 2,000 km, mostly combined, connected to a treatment plant whose treated water is used in particular to irrigate golf courses and green spaces. New districts and subdivisions may, however, be designed as separate or partially separate systems (part of the stormwater, from roofs for example, joins the wastewater network). Ask the operator for its requirements before designing the network: they are binding on the project.
The design rules to know
- Self-cleansing: the gradient must be even so that the water reaches a sufficient velocity, around 0.6 to 0.75 m/s, and carries away deposits.
- Minimum diameters: 200 mm is commonly used for wastewater sewers and 300 mm for stormwater or combined sewers. These are usual values, to be confirmed in the operator's specifications.
- Manholes at every change of direction, gradient or diameter, and at regular intervals on straight runs.
- Stormwater flow: it is calculated from the impervious area and the rainfall intensity. In Marrakech, annual rainfall is low, but storms are violent and short: they are what governs the sizing.
What about a villa?
Even if the street has a combined sewer, separate wastewater and stormwater inside your plot up to the connection chamber. This lets you harvest rainwater, infiltrate part of the roof water and connect easily if a separate network is built later. Never connect a rainwater downpipe to a septic tank: it would overflow at every storm.
The role of the engineering firm
The engineering firm calculates the flows, sets the gradients and diameters, locates the manholes and checks the level of the public sewer to determine whether discharge can be by gravity or whether a lifting station is needed. It also prepares the connection application submitted to the operator.
Frequently asked questions
Does Marrakech have a combined or separate sewer system?
The Marrakech sewer network is described as mostly combined; new districts may be on a separate system, depending on the network operator's requirements.
What velocity is needed in a sewer to avoid deposits?
The aim is a self-cleansing velocity of around 0.6 to 0.75 m/s, obtained with an even gradient along the whole length of the sewer.
Should stormwater and wastewater be separated in a villa?
Yes, it is recommended up to the connection chamber, even if the street is on a combined system: it makes rainwater harvesting and a future separate connection easier.
A project in the pipeline?
SIGMA ICC designs reinforced concrete, electrical, plumbing and HVAC systems and supervises sites for villas, riads, hotels and shops.
Sources : SuSanA, fiche réseaux d'égouts · Mémoire FST, assainissement de Marrakech · GIZ et ministère de l'Équipement, manuel des réseaux d'assainissement (2019).